APS Logo

Principles for Curriculum Design while Teaching about Ethics, Physics, and Society

ORAL

Abstract

Physics has greatly impacted society, both in solving problems and perpetuating harm, yet we rarely provide opportunities for physics students to grapple with their responsibilities to society. The absence of direct discussions about the intersections of science and society in classrooms can reinforce the idea that physics is purely objective and removed from societal impact or influence. This messaging can justify students' disengagement from social responsibility, leave them unprepared to use ethical reasoning in their careers, and isolate students who feel commitment to their communities. Although many instructors value these types of conversations, their implementation in the classroom can be daunting. From research across three course contexts which included ethics discussions (a modern physics course, an observational astrophysics course, and a multi-disciplinary STEM ethics course), we identified features which supported students in building comfort, competence, nuance, and agency around complex ethical issues in physics. This talk will share these curricular design features, as a framework to support other instructors in developing and implementing lessons about the intersections of science and society in their physics classrooms.

Publication: Alice Olmstead, Brianne Gutmann, Egla Ochoa-Madrid, Alexander Vasquez, Ciana Pike, Daniel Barringer; How Can We Design Instruction to Support Student Reasoning About Physicists' Ethical Responsibilities in Society?. Phys. Teach. 1 May 2023; 61 (5): 343–350. https://doi.org/10.1119/5.0087490<br><br>Egla Ochoa-Madrid, Alice R. Olmstead, and Brianne Gutmann. "Characterizing physics students' ethical reasoning after a unit on the development of the atomic bomb." Physics Education Research Conference 2019. Provo, UT: 2019. 423-428 of PER Conference. 25 Oct. 2024 <https://www.compadre.org/Repository/document/ServeFile.cfm?ID=15312&DocID=5224>.<br><br>Brianne Gutmann, Egla Ochoa-Madrid, and Alice R. Olmstead. ""I'm not that important": Barriers and bolsters to student agency during conversations about the intersections of physics and ethics." Physics Education Research Conference 2020. Virtual Conference: 2020. 191-197 of PER Conference. 25 Oct. 2024 <https://www.compadre.org/Repository/document/ServeFile.cfm?ID=15482&DocID=5330>.

Presenters

  • Brianne Gutmann

    San Jose State University

Authors

  • Brianne Gutmann

    San Jose State University

  • Alice R Olmstead

    Texas State University

  • Egla Ochoa-Madrid

    Texas State University

  • Alexander Mendez Vasquez

    Texas State University

  • Danny Barringer

    San Jose State University

  • Ciana Pike

    Università degli Studi di Padova