3 General Concerns and 12 Errors in Einstein's Paper and Book on Special Relativity
ORAL
Abstract
If we look at relativistic theory from the perspective of the rationality of the physical model, we will find various errors caused by the incorrect physical models. Most of these errors are relatively simple and intuitive. A few that are not intuitive enough can also be clearly proved. We discussed several before [21], but now we have new understanding also to those discussed now.
This article is mainly discussing about 12 problems related to the special theory of relativity in Einstein’s paper “On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies [1]” and book “Relativity: Special and General Theory [2].”
First, three generic defects about the system of relativity were pointed out first. The two reference bodies used in a relativistic system should be given some conditions in their application. Without these limiting conditions, the application was not reasonable.
We named three concerns about the application limitation conditions a system of relativity should have below:
a) Theory of relativity should specify the distance or their positions between the two reference bodies.
b) It needs specify the quality of the reference bodies.
c) It needs specify how two reference bodies are bound to each other to form a relativistic system.
Then, we give the 12 problems we are discussing in this paper as follows:
Problem-1). The synchronous transfer rule defined by Einstein is wrong.
Problem-2). The simultaneity transfer rule defined by Einstein is wrong.
Problem-3). Can the law of the constancy of the speed of light in a vacuum be maintained?
Problem-4). Einstein used a wrong composed object to be a reference body.
Problem-5). Einstein discussed special relativity extensively using a system that was not a relativistic system.
Problem-6). Einstein’s wrong light speed example.
Problem-7). Another wrong light speed example used by Einstein.
Problem-8). Why a raven can’t be a reference body be relative to running train carriage?
Problem-9). How to use theory of relativity to wipe out any enemy?
Problem-10). How can pure mathematic make the moving length shorten and time dilation?
Problem-11). Freely switch the reference bodies causes big trouble.
Problem-12). Einstein against the existence of the absolute simultaneity, but we prove there are many relativistic systems maintain absolute simultaneity.
This article is mainly discussing about 12 problems related to the special theory of relativity in Einstein’s paper “On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies [1]” and book “Relativity: Special and General Theory [2].”
First, three generic defects about the system of relativity were pointed out first. The two reference bodies used in a relativistic system should be given some conditions in their application. Without these limiting conditions, the application was not reasonable.
We named three concerns about the application limitation conditions a system of relativity should have below:
a) Theory of relativity should specify the distance or their positions between the two reference bodies.
b) It needs specify the quality of the reference bodies.
c) It needs specify how two reference bodies are bound to each other to form a relativistic system.
Then, we give the 12 problems we are discussing in this paper as follows:
Problem-1). The synchronous transfer rule defined by Einstein is wrong.
Problem-2). The simultaneity transfer rule defined by Einstein is wrong.
Problem-3). Can the law of the constancy of the speed of light in a vacuum be maintained?
Problem-4). Einstein used a wrong composed object to be a reference body.
Problem-5). Einstein discussed special relativity extensively using a system that was not a relativistic system.
Problem-6). Einstein’s wrong light speed example.
Problem-7). Another wrong light speed example used by Einstein.
Problem-8). Why a raven can’t be a reference body be relative to running train carriage?
Problem-9). How to use theory of relativity to wipe out any enemy?
Problem-10). How can pure mathematic make the moving length shorten and time dilation?
Problem-11). Freely switch the reference bodies causes big trouble.
Problem-12). Einstein against the existence of the absolute simultaneity, but we prove there are many relativistic systems maintain absolute simultaneity.
–
Publication: Wu, Sean Yuxiang, Five Errors that Have Never Been Discussed Over the Theory of Special Relativity, Applied Physics Research; Vol. 16, No. 1; 2024. https://ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/apr/article/view/0/49839
Presenters
-
Sean Yuxiang Wu
2W Object
Authors
-
Sean Yuxiang Wu
2W Object
-
Lü Wu
2W Object