Method of moments comparison for soot population modeling in turbulent combustion

Representation of soot population is an important component in the efficient computational prediction of particulate emissions. However, there are a number of moments-based techniques with varying numerical complexity. In the past, development of such methods has been principally carried out on canonical laminar and 0-D flows. However, their applications in realistic solvers developed for turbulent combustion may face challenges from turbulence closure to selection of moment sets. In this work, the accuracy and relative computational expense of a few common soot method of moments are tested in canonical turbulent flames for different configurations. Large eddy simulation (LES) will be used as the turbulence modeling framework. In grid-filtered LES, the interaction of numerical and modeling errors is a first-order problem that can undermine the accuracy of soot predictions. In the past, special moments-based methods for solvers that transport high frequency content fluid with ability to reconstruct particle size distribution have been developed. Here, a similar analysis will be carried out for the moment-based soot modeling approaches above. Specifically, realizability of moments methods with nonlinear advection schemes will be discussed.